Choosing what to do

Author: Warren Peece | Created: 2010-04-24 7:56 | Last Activity: 2010-04-27 22:35

Original Post

2010-04-24 7:56
In the late 1990's the BBC made a TV drama called THE MISSING POSTMAN (starring James Bolam). It's about a postman who decides to deliver the mail personally to various addresses in the UK (instead of the through the normal system). He gets to Scotland and stays for some time with a lady who had a simple way of choosing what to do. She would write a task, job etc on a slip of paper and place it in a big jar. When she wanted to choose what to do she would dip into the jar and pull out a task. Seems like a good way to make a choice when choosing is hard to do.

Anyway, I thought I'd make a (hopefully light hearted) contribution to the discussion. BTW - I think most of the programme is available on YouTube

All the best ... WP

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-24 8:02
You know, I think I vaguely remember that. It's a similar method to "The Diceman" by Luke Rheinhart http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dice_Man (warning: some strong language in this link).

I've always thought a degree of randomness was quite a good thing in life. It stops us getting into too much of a rut, and also stops us agonising over some decisions. It can lead to new experiences.

See my article:
http://www.markforster.net/blog/2007/3/5/the-random-element-how-to-get-out-of-the-rut.html

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-24 9:15
Mark Forster:

"The Diceman." "Strong Language."

[This is the space where a litany of incredibly offensive jokes mocking an late 80's comedy icon would be, if I had one iota less of self-restraint and respect for the tone of this board, OH!]

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-24 9:41
From Mark's blog post above:

"One of the things which often holds us back from making decisions is the belief that we must make the “right” decision. Sometimes people will put off making necessary decisions for years, possibly even for a lifetime, because they are afraid that they might be making the “wrong” decision. But the truth is that there is are no right and no wrong decisions, only decisions with different consequences."

This is the kinda stuff I like to preach, but been having a hard time practicing lately. Have a "big" decision looming overhead.

No matter how I decide or whether I do or not, things are gonna change in my life significantly.

I used to rarely decide anything. People think that in itself is a decision. It's not. "Decide" means to cut off. To remove all options and commit yourself to what is left.

Choosing coursework. I think for months after not deciding whether or not to take a course on topology, I was still weight the pros and cons. I was weighing the pros and cons at times after the course was over. I hadn't decided yet. I never made that decision.

I don't engage in that kinda nonsense anymore, except in "big" decisions. The decision I face matters a lot to me and to others around me and to many who I do not know.

It would take some kinda chutzpah to roll dice or flip a coin on this one.

Reply by Chris Cooper

2010-04-24 10:08
Norman, I'm always interested in your posts, and I'd like to know what the one above means:

> [This is the space where a litany of incredibly offensive jokes mocking an late 80's comedy icon would be,

I'm not telepathic. What late 80s comedy icon?

> if I had one iota less of self-restraint and respect for the tone of this board, OH!]

I'm tired of googling for acronyms. What does "OH" mean?

Reply by RogerJ

2010-04-24 10:11
As bad as "Truly Tasteless Jokes" by Blanche Knott?

I picked it up in Johannesburg in the 1980s and it helped us get through some incredibly boring afternoon sessions in week-long MBA schools (unrelated snippet: my group emerged top of the class at the end of the four year part-time program for academic achievement).

I can still see one of my colleagues crying with laughter in both eyes, unusual because John only has one eye, like my UK optometrist (yes, really). I think it was the one about the bloke who had a baby elephant's trunk transplanted to replace his chopped-off male member. Crude, it was, but also funny.

So, c'mon Norman, which other forums do you inhabit that would permit your litany? However, I think the passing years since the 1980s might have made me less tolerant of some brands of alleged humour. I used to think anything goes, that humour is one lifebelt that keeps us afloat in life's stormy seas, but these days, maybe not.

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-24 10:20
Andrew Dice Clay, often called "The Diceman."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Dice_Clay

The "OH" comes from his tagging his jokes by barking "oh" in his corny affect of a Jersey Gindaloon accent.

You can google around and find some of his schtick. It really is pretty offensive stuff for most people and actually is pretty terrible. He was huge for a minute. He was able to pack arenas with his act.

Probably the best thing that came outta the Diceman phenomenon was Gilbert Gottfried's absurd reduction of Dice's material. Gottfried still does the bit. It's hilarious, especially since most folks have no idea what he is doing.

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-24 10:26
"So, c'mon Norman, which other forums do you inhabit that would permit your litany?"

More than you would think. Usually the language is so blue it is black and the humor so off-color it is ultraviolet.

Pretty much the way most people I hang out with in "real life" are.

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2010-04-24 13:35
"I used to rarely decide anything. People think that in itself is a decision. It's not. "Decide" means to cut off. To remove all options and commit yourself to what is left."

How dare you disagree with RUSH and "Tom Sawyer"?! The truth is though that often inaction is effectively the same as choosing not to participate. If the boat leaves tomorrow and you're not on it, essentially you chose not to go, even if you were not of clear opinion.

Reply by learning as I go

2010-04-24 13:58
Hi Alan B.
Well stated. Often times I've used this gimmick when my ego is interfering with my good sense! lol!
vickie

Reply by Jacqueline

2010-04-24 14:14
My son and I play the dice game quite often since I found it for lots of things. He loves it, so do I.
Here's a video of guys that play it on their travel adventures.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aiuCFWqVab8

I found it through Luke Rhinehart's "Book of est" and the philosophy of the game is very aligned with est. But that's another thread.

Reply by Mel

2010-04-24 14:28
Mark: Another good blog post. Thanks for sharing it. As I'm leaving for vacation in a week, I can see my kids getting a big kick out of choosing a place to eat that way. I just hope we wouldn't end up at a biker bar! Though the biker crowd having aged considerably would probably be pretty safe. ;-)

Jacqueline: I started doing that a bit with the kids and chores. I have six kids so I write down six chores and whatever number they roll (that hasn't already been taken) is their chore. The cool thing is they don't complain as the die has assigned it.

Reply by Jacqueline

2010-04-24 15:19
An article on Rhinehart and playing the dice:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2000/aug/27/fiction.timadams

"using dice occasionally 'would have some beneficial effect for everyone. It is probable that just the act of listing six things you might do on a particular day will open up possibilities that you would never otherwise have considered. Allowing you to replace "What must I do?" with "What could I do.."

Mel, I know what you mean, they just love the games, don't they? Now try it on your vacation... :-) I like the aspect of asking random strangers where to go or what to do so that you don't even have your own filters on for a list of possible things to do.

You could apply this to an AF-style list. Say you have six goals or projects, write them down on a list and roll the dice for what you will work on at any point in time (assuming no deadlines). Then just keep rolling because it doesn't matter what you choose as long as you keep moving - if it's a direction you want to go that is and aren't willing to let it go totally to chance. I might experiment with that this week. :-)

Reply by Mel

2010-04-24 15:59
Jacqueline, I have been thinking the same thing. This could be a fun twist for homeschooling too. My kids love to change things up as much as I do.

Reply by Simon

2010-04-24 16:45
I tried this actually on my AF1 list for about a week last winter. I numbered all of the open tasks and then used Excel to randomly choose a number. Even if it chose an extremely unpleasant task, I applied "little and often" -- ie had to take at least one small step toward moving the task forward.

It worked surprisingly well for the first three or four days -- a lot of things I'd been dreading or postponing were accomplished, and also there was no feeling of "overwhelm" from a long AF list because I knew eventually everything would get done (on some random day in the future).

In the end though I dropped it because of (a) the old problem that completing one task inevitably leads to two more (and so the list just got bigger and bigger), and (b) looking back at that week, it seems mostly filled with "busy work".

Basically you're bypassing your rational and intuitive side, which can be a good idea for a few days if you're locked in negative mental patterns (eg pessimism or fatigue). But eventually a gulf opens up between what your rational and/or intuitive side want to do, and what the random system is choosing for you, and that actually creates a new source of stress.

Eventually what you need to do becomes really obvious, and you don't need the training wheels of the random list any longer.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-24 16:51
Of course the truth is that most people's life tends to be pretty random anyway.

I mean if one wrote a list of things which one was intending to do today, someone could open a book on which ones you would actually get round to:

Have breakfast 1/100,
Clear email Evens,
Write report which you have been putting off for weeks 10/1.

And how much of what your life is like today could you have predicted 20 years ago?

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-24 18:38
Found these techniques helpful in more "trivial" group decisions. A dozen or so of us at work usually take a longer lunch off campus on Fridays. Trying to decide were to go would pretty much start as soon as the work day did. And more than a few times the group would split and end up going to two places instead of one.

Then I asked everyone to write down their top five favorite places to go on Friday. I made a list of the results, noting how many times a choice was selected.

Ended up with about 20 suggestions within those 100 or so votes. Wrote a script to "randomly" select one of those suggestions with relative weight given to the popularity of each selection.

RIght before lunch, we all get together and hit the "roll" button and see where we are going and go.

Reply by Mel

2010-04-24 21:57
Simon, thanks for that report on how randomly generated AF works. I was pretty sure that's how it would fall out eventually. But I do like the idea for an occasional change of pace. Interesting you mention "training wheels." This week I've discovered I really act helpless sometimes as though I don't know what I should be doing. The truth is I know EXACTLY what I should be doing; I just don't want to do it. I've been more intentional about just doing what needs doing. The same holds true for problem solving. There are times I pretend I don't know the solution to one of my difficulties when the truth is if I friend had the same difficulty, I'd have no problem sharing the solution.

Mark: That's pretty funny putting odds on getting things done. My family would be able to predict very well, especially my husband. In the past he has LOL at my ambitious daily to-do list, as well he should have. ;-) As for being able to predict my life now from 20 years before, I'm sure it's my age (42), but I would have been way off. The only thing I wouldn't be surprised about is the writing and speaking.

Norman: That's a neat idea. I have an iPhone app that will essentially do the same thing. You can set an area and a cuisine or leave those open and "roll." Wish I could say I've used it! Maybe on the next rare occasion I go out, I'll give it a spin.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-25 2:15
Mark: I don't agree that I could have predicted where I'd be right now with any degree of accuracy. I certainly could not have predicted the path I have taken.

As to the random way of picking tasks, I get that one might get stuck and need an emergency fix of this kind. (In fact, it seems kind of a neatly simple answer to that kind of problem.) But, OTOH, what would be the point of running one's whole life this way? It seems to me that abdicates the responsibility of living. Even if I were to decide to randomly choose from a task list ... I'd rationally choose the items to put on the list before I randomly selected them.

Reply by JD

2010-04-25 2:46
<>

Aren't you actually agreeing with what Mark said, Mike?

Reply by Warren Peece

2010-04-25 14:39
Mark - I should have guessed that you would have already considered and tried a "Random Choice Selector" . As a very "button down" type of person the freedom from the stress of choosing - by taking a completely random approach from time to time sounds very exciting - and I'm going to give it a go.

Simon - rather than rewriting all my things to do on small slips of paper and putting them in a bit jar I was thinking of using some sort of random number generator so I found your experience very interesting. It's helped me to clarify my thinking and to come to the conclusion that random choice would be good for blowing a breath of fresh air through my task management approach from time to time but my day to day approach is just grinding through my lists (AF1 style).

BTW Norman U your recent post that included a line about the incompetent people you work with tickled my fancy - I thought I was the only one who inflicted that on my ever patient wife - so reading your post lifted my spirits.

And if anyone's interested I'm reading "The Heart of Christianity" by Marcus Borg at the moment and finding it very thought provoking and I don't have to worry about what to do tomorrow because it's the ANZAC DAY public holiday here in Sydney tomorrow so I can put TM on hold and start again on Tuesday.

All the best ... WP

Reply by Mel

2010-04-25 19:45
Warren, I had not heard of Marcus Borg before you posted. From reading reviews, I expect my views to diverge widely from his, but I'm interested to know about his writings. Let us know how you like it. I have never read C. S. Lewis's Mere Christianity and you've inspired me to get it off my bookshelf and read it! Thanks.

Reply by Warren Peece

2010-04-26 9:33
Mel,

C.S Lewis is one of my favourite authors - he influenced my views when I first started reading his books some years ago. I also liked his Screwtape books. Although some of his language is a bit dated now I still like to dip in from time to time. apart from the Bible, Thomas a Kempis was also important to me for a while - but less so now. I'm finding Mr Borg's book quite challenging. Iniitially I baulked at his writing but the more I read the more I think he makes a lot of sense. Anyway, I'll keep reading and let you know how I go (so long as Mark and the other "senior" members of the discussion forum have no objections).

All the best ... WP

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-26 13:11
JD:

<< Aren't you actually agreeing with what Mark said, Mike? >>

Mike always disagrees with me as a matter of principle, even when what he's saying is exactly the same as I've just said.

Reply by Jacqueline

2010-04-26 17:05
I don't think the emphasis should be on how you can predict what you're going to be *doing* anyway, it should be on how you are *being*. And that's what you ideally want to look at changing if it's not supporting you.

I could predict that in 5 years if learning as I go had a severe setback, she would come through it as a survivor. Mike would be playing devil's advocate somewhere, Norman would be searching for enlightenment and still be acerbic, David will be overwhelmed with too much to do... it's all how you choose to play the game. And your way of being determines how you play and whether you win the game, not what you take on as a goal or direction.

I think what the point of Rhinehart's work - or one of them is - that you can choose how to play, as everyone has many choices of ways of being, they just don't tend to see it. They get stuck in their way of interacting with the world.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-26 17:21
Mark,

>>> Mike always disagrees with me as a matter of principle, even when what he's saying is exactly the same as I've just said. <<<

Only when you are wrong. ;-) In this case, I'm STILL not sure what it is that you said that I disagreed with -- or agreed with. That can often take more parsing than the underlying words support ;-) After reading and rereading your post several times I concluded that I BOTH agreed and disagreed because you post seemed to say BOTH that life was determined and random (and perhaps statistically predictable?) I'm still not entirely sure. At least that was what I managed to tease out of it ;-)

I note how much more meaning I have been able to get from Norman's posts now that he has loosened up his miserly grip on his precious words and uses enough to allow meaning to slip through ;-)

Lostsa words ;-) ;-)

Reply by Mike

2010-04-26 17:33
Hey J,

Yes, that 'bout nails it. Personality is more persistent and overarching than the particular existential bits.

I kind of like the way Richard Brodie puts it: (Particularly the last sentences!)

"Life is largely composed of conversations. Conversations are composed of memes. In Level 1 we are unaware of this. In Level 2 we see the world as a solid, understandable body to be interacted with. In Level 3 we see the world as a canvas to be painted, an instrument to be played, or a block of marble to be sculpted by us for our purpose. We choose to do this for good or for evil. If we choose good, good is returned to us in unexpected ways. If we choose evil, evil is returned. Either way, it looks like the way we choose is the way of the world."

And, of course, "good" and "evil" oversimplifies, IMO. Substitute any world view for "good/evil" and that sentiment holds true, essentially. And given that it is basically a reworking of Transcendentalism, I'm sure that Norman (and perhaps Mark) would agree. We shall see ;-)

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-26 18:01
Mike:

<< In this case, I'm STILL not sure what it is that you said that I disagreed with -- or agreed with. >>

JD didn't seem to have any trouble understanding what I said. Come to that, I never had any problem understanding Norman's posts - even though I can scarcely register at all on his scale of how intelligent we are compared to him.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-26 18:03
Mike:

<< it is basically a reworking of Transcendentalism >>

Or possibly even of "As you sow, so shall you reap", which is a lot older than Transcendentalism.

Reply by Mel

2010-04-26 18:30
Jacqueline, you're right about predicting in that way. In high school I was doing more than should have been humanly possible. It isn't really that surprising that I'm writing, speaking, and homeschooling six kids.

Mike, I'm in shock that you used the phrase "world view." Is it okay to use as long as it isn't applied to you? lol Hope you're having a good week.

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-26 18:40
Mike:

"I note how much more meaning I have been able to get from Norman's posts now that he has loosened up his miserly grip on his precious words and uses enough to allow meaning to slip through"

Its called dumbing down your material for your readers.

Reply by Jacqueline

2010-04-26 19:11
It's depressing how quickly predictions come true. :-(

Hey Mike, thanks for the Brodie reference. I knew he had a meme book out (haven't read it), but didn't realize he'd rewritten Emerson's Self-Reliance and it's posted on his site.

Mark, you might like this restaurant story:
http://www.memecentral.com/L3Ordering.htm

Mel, you might like this:
http://www.memecentral.com/L3HaveWant.htm

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-26 20:31
Jacqueline, you really take yourself too seriously.

People survive who happen to survive. It is a tautology. Not much of a merit badge involved.

If Mike were the Devil's advocate, he would have been fired along time ago (pardon the pun).

There is nothing to search for, except perhaps my car keys which I seem to be incapable of keeping track of.

Do not trust anyone who uses "meme", "Transcendentalism", "existential", "world view", "good and evil", and "levels" as metaphors to describe anything less concrete than a building within the span of a lifetime, much less a single post.

And describing me as acerbic is about the sweetest thing you could ever do.

I do have a rep to maintain. If I didn't live down to your expectations, how would I ever surprise you?

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-26 20:47
Mark:

"Or possibly even of "As you sow, so shall you reap", which is a lot older than Transcendentalism."

This old saw, I find to be exceptionally dangerous. In some sense it is true and has been written down in the Western tradition since Hesiod's _Works and Days_. The little truth it does contain is rather obvious and not very illuminating. But the moral implications can end up rather monstrous in my opinion.

From the plague which devastated Athens without apparent relation to the virtue of the people it destroyed to the Lisbon earthquake to the recent Haitian disaster,to why some people get cancer and do not recover and others do, etc, this idea can be rather ugly in my opinion especially when torn from the context of the entire complicated text in which lies.

The metaphor is faulty anyhow. Sometimes what you sow does not come to harvest due to conditions outside your control or you fortuitously find a crop spring forth you did not plant.

Personally,I find this fragment much more in line with the way of the world:

"That ye may be the children of your Father which is in heaven: for he maketh his sun to rise on the evil and on the good, and sendeth rain on the just and on the unjust."

Reply by Jacqueline

2010-04-26 21:59
What use is my "What Would Norman Do?" bracelet that I'm using to guide every decision in my life if I can't rely on you to be consistent?

Reply by Seraphim

2010-04-26 23:30
"As you sow, so shall you reap"

does not imply

"All you reap, you have previously sown"

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-27 3:06
Of course it implies that. As well as other things. What a snippet of text implies is based on its context. And that snippet of text has been contextualized in many ways.

Maybe across the pound where nutty stuff like Calvinism, Transcendentalism, New Thought, Unitarianism, New Age, 12 Step Movements and what not did not catch on as much, you have more robust understanding of such words. In America, just watch when anyone is suffering, more and more our discourse locates the entire fault within the person. The suffering, even nowadays cancer, is result of ill deeds and now the thoughts! of the one who suffers.

Our language of the pain and suffering of others revolves more around blame and justice than love, compassion, and healing.

Americans loves lines like one quoted above and the more Biblically astute find much comfort in story of Jacob and Essau as proof of the divine meritorious nature of the success they find in life and the pain and suffering others find.

When we Americans are at best, we blame entire populations of countries for natural disasters which befall them.

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-27 3:11
Seraphim,

"As you sow, so shall you reap"

does not imply

"All you reap, you have previously sown"

BTW, I pointed out this logically unnecessary implication already. But humans and small quotes of "words of God" often don't behave or act in the most logical or compassionate manner.

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-27 5:19
Jacqueline:

"What use is my "What Would Norman Do?" bracelet that I'm using to guide every decision in my life if I can't rely on you to be consistent?"

If in doubt, spend a lot of time staring at walls and ceilings. I find this answers most of life's problems.

Reply by Mel

2010-04-27 6:17
Norman: I, too, am fiddling with my WWND bracelet. I'm not sure what you mean about Jacob and Esau. This is clearly not a story of success vs. failure. Jacob's account of his life wouldn't be a happy rags-to-riches tale. In fact, he would be an Oprah favorite, wouldn't he? He had two wives who were terribly jealous of one another, a father who didn't favor him, a father-in-law who cheated him, a wife who died in childbirth after he foolishly proclaimed that whoever had his FIL's gods would die, a daughter who was raped, a son who was sold off into slavery (who he thought had died), another son who slept with his concubine. I could go on...

Neither was Esau the poor soul you might expect him to be given his rebellion in marrying godless women and his carelessness with his birthright. In fact, he became a very wealthy man. Reaping what you sow is a general principle and just as we don't really know why some seed germinates and some doesn't, we shouldn't comment on why tragedy befalls another. God alone knows.

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-27 6:24
Mel, where do you live?

Reply by Will

2010-04-27 8:23
Norman,

It would be just rude of me to comment on the foibles of some of your countrymen. Here in the UK we have plenty of people ready to blame others for their own (the others' own) misfortune. Although you don't hear much about Haitian religion, for instance, people have commented that it was the richest country in the Caribbean until their revolution. The point being, presumably, that freedom from enlightened European rule is bad for you.

The real problem with freedom, of course, is that you only have yourself to blame. Which can be trying.

My knowledge of C17th English grammar is not perfect, but I'm pretty sure that this phrase establishes a 1-1 mapping between reaping and sowing. As a Deep Truth, this is a bit on the obvious side. But as a practical reminder to keep investing in the long term it is helpful. Consider the traditional "important vs urgent" grid for evaluating your commitments. Replace it with "important (current goals) vs investing (growth)".

This is one of Nicholas Bates' key themes.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 8:39
Norman:

You seem to be reaping what you have sown on this Forum quite successfully.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 9:49
Mark,

>>> JD didn't seem to have any trouble understanding what I said. <<<

Ah, but then JD must be plugged into the Matrix, I suppose ;-)

>>> Come to that, I never had any problem understanding Norman's posts - even though I can scarcely register at all on his scale of how intelligent we are compared to him. <<<

See, now while that seems obvious in meaning at first blush, when I actually parse it I can't get to the golden nugget within promised by the poetry of its construction without. A problem which keeps me tossing and turning at nights if I read yours or Norman's post too soon before bedtime.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 9:55
Mark,

>>> Or possibly even of "As you sow, so shall you reap", which is a lot older than Transcendentalism. <<<

Well yes as to transcendentalism ... which is really an attempt to explain the biblical quote -- among other things. A cause and effect kind of thing going on there.

But not so much Brodie's take on memetics. Brodie is, as I read him, not so much attempting to address the physical consequences of ones actions (though he does) but the psychological ones (that the world will seem to be constructed in such a way as to support your belief in how it is constructed). Which I find a far more interesting observation.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 9:58
Mel,

>>> Mike, I'm in shock that you used the phrase "world view." <<<

I can't imagine why.

>>> Is it okay to use as long as it isn't applied to you? lol <<<

Now you are doing a "Mark" on me ... I have absolutely NO idea what that means.

>>> Hope you're having a good week. <<<

A week like any other, I suppose. It has had its ups and downs.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 10:12
Norman,

>>> Its called dumbing down your material for your readers. <<<

Ehhh, not so much, I think. The way I see it ... the purpose of writing is to communicate. Successful communication is achieved when the person at the other end has in his mind a good understanding of YOUR idea which he can then use to express agreement or disagreement (hopefully in terms as clear). While it may be satisfying to express an idea as a poem, or with the minimum possible number of words, or in Homeric Greek, or possibly even as a palindrome ... the audience for whom that communication is successful is rather limited ... so as communication it fails. It might be SELF-satisfying, but not successful communication. And if not successful communication, what is the point? .You'll end up with no readers anyway.

Perhaps I should take a whack at devising a left recursive grammar based on the rules of AF1 to post here and see how I fare. Oh, now here's a thought: I wonder if Norman's posts would pass the Turing Test.

Just funnin' 'ya Norman. Your autobiographical piece was nicely done and put to rest any argument that there is no one behind the curtain ;)

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 10:27
Hey Norman,

>>> Jacqueline, you really take yourself too seriously. <<<

OMG, I can't imagine anyone who takes herself LESS seriously.

>>> People survive who happen to survive. It is a tautology.<<<

You've just got to get a handle on the real meaning of that word! First of all, it applies to logical argument (particularly in the context mathematical logic) not to the "real world". People survive because they DO things which ACCOMPLISH survival. It is not an accidental thing. (At least not for some!)

>>> Not much of a merit badge involved. <<<

Norman, I know you are a much better person than one who would diminish the value of persistence of Sisyphus. Personally, I've found that recognizing courage is more than fair and just ... it is downright useful.

>>> If Mike were the Devil's advocate, he would have been fired along time ago (pardon the pun). <<<

Possibly true, but then that is strictly an honorary office, not an elected one for which I am campaigning.

>>> There is nothing to search for, except perhaps my car keys which I seem to be incapable of keeping track of. <<<

I dunno ;-) Meaining springs to mind ;-)

>>> Do not trust anyone who uses "meme", "Transcendentalism", "existential", "world view", "good and evil", and "levels" as metaphors to describe anything less concrete than a building within the span of a lifetime, much less a single post. <<<

I wonder why the term "trust" springs to mind. And how those terms -- conceptual ones -- would apply to things "concrete". Or why you have trouble with those particular terms. Ah, the questions are endless.

>>> And describing me as acerbic is about the sweetest thing you could ever do. <<<

And you implied that she did not have a sense of humor! LOL ;-)

>>> I do have a rep to maintain. If I didn't live down to your expectations, how would I ever surprise you? <<<

Ashleigh Brilliantesque!

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 10:52
Norman Norman Norman, your posts here are so vexingly conflicted! OY!

>>> This old saw, I find to be exceptionally dangerous. In some sense it is true and has been written down in the Western tradition since Hesiod's _Works and Days_. The little truth it does contain is rather obvious and not very illuminating. But the moral implications can end up rather monstrous in my opinion. <<<

Well, of COURSE the truth is obvious. Truth usually IS -- once it is perceived! As to how illuminating it is ... how illuminating is ANY truth? It seems that the illumination mostly comes from the lamp by which it is read. And what kind of monstrosity do you find lurking within. The admonition is not: "You will be guranteed success if you follow the right formula." Rather it is the CONVERSE of that: "If you sow corn don't expect wheat."

>>> From the plague which devastated Athens without apparent relation to the virtue of the people it destroyed to the Lisbon earthquake to the recent Haitian disaster,to why some people get cancer and do not recover and others do, etc, this idea can be rather ugly in my opinion especially when torn from the context of the entire complicated text in which lies. <<<

I dunno, it always seemed rather obvious to me. In fact, you are the first person ... in all of my years, who I've run across who had a problem with it.

>>> The metaphor is faulty anyhow. Sometimes what you sow does not come to harvest due to conditions outside your control or you fortuitously find a crop spring forth you did not plant. <<<

But that misreads the meaning of it. It does not promise a positive outcome ... it warns that failing to note what you are planting might result in a nasty surprise. The admonition would apply more to your concern is the one about the seeds on rocky soil that don't take root, etc. A different metaphor for a different message. These books of teaching stories have lots of them and they need to be applied to the right situations to be understood. But then these stories were meant for the illiterate and uneducated so it might be hard to get past that if one has a monstrous intellect ;-)

>>> Personally,I find this fragment much more in line with the way of the world:

"That ye may be the children of your Father which is in heaven: for he maketh his sun to rise on the evil and on the good, and sendeth rain on the just and on the unjust." <<<

But they ALL describe the world ... just different aspects of it. There is no one platitude to cover all cases. This one has an entirely different message to convey: "Don't expect that being good is going to gurantee success in all things." Or, another similar platitude: "Virtue is its own reward."

This is exactly why that Brodie observation is most interesting: The world will SEEM to be exactly what you BELIEVE it to be. Or put more prosaically: Your beliefs will provide the evidence you need to continue believing them.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 11:09
Norman,

>>> Of course it implies that. As well as other things. What a snippet of text implies is based on its context. And that snippet of text has been contextualized in many ways. <<<

Yeah, but the most basic and well understood meaning is that "if you want X, then DO X". If you want good, do good. If you want success, work for it. If you want people to like you, then like people ... etc. It is not really DEEP THOUGH ;-)

>>> Maybe across the pound where nutty stuff like Calvinism, Transcendentalism, New Thought, Unitarianism, New Age, 12 Step Movements and what not did not catch on as much, you have more robust understanding of such words. In America, <<<

OWWW, my brain hurts. First of all, let me just say that Seraphim is not across any pond. There are damn few ponds anywhere NEAR where he lives ... in Arizona. (And no, I'm not going to reveal the whereabouts of Mel. LOL ;-)

But more than that, why do you lump that collection of ideas into one pot and call them "nutty". I find some useful things in most all of them. Hell, even the 12 step programs, dismal failures though they are, have something to recommend them.

>>> just watch when anyone is suffering, more and more our discourse locates the entire fault within the person. The suffering, even nowadays cancer, is result of ill deeds and now the thoughts! of the one who suffers. <<<

Well, what ever is true is true. I certainly think that posting universal causes for things is misguided. I'd argue that even the "germ theory" has it wrong. Clearly there are multiple causes for most things. You can expose two people to the same "germs" and one will sicken and die and the other will go on about his business. As to cancer, it is demonstrably true that thoughts can play a role in it. People such as Louise Hay take it too far in that direction, but I assure you that if I had cancer I'd be working to improve my mental outlook as well as doing radiation or chemo or whatever else. It is just as misguided to cite one thing as the cause as to exclude the possibility of one thing from having ANY causal role.

>>> Our language of the pain and suffering of others revolves more around blame and justice than love, compassion, and healing. <<<

Norman, for a person who aims at crafting words, that seems to be quite a bit of fog just there. What on earth can one get from "love, compassion, and healing"? Just above you are appealing to a "robust meaning" for words. Geeez ;-)

>>> Americans loves lines like one quoted above and the more Biblically astute find much comfort in story of Jacob and Essau as proof of the divine meritorious nature of the success they find in life and the pain and suffering others find.

When we Americans are at best, we blame entire populations of countries for natural disasters which befall them. <<<

Oh good grief. ALL AMERICANS blame entire populations? Why not say that "All people blame others" and just leave it at that?

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 11:32
Hey J, where did you buy your WWND bracelet? I've been using my cats as my oracle but staring into their eyes has been not so much informative as causing some dizziness and headaches. I'm sure the bracelet will be just the ticket ... an answer to my every quandary.

I'm not sure of the point of searching texts (the result of multiple politically motivated translations of platitudes designed to teach basic ethics to ancient nomads) to gain wisdom in living life in the 21st century high tech society. Would it not make more sense to quote passages from "How to Win Friends and Influence People"? Certainly more relevant in today's world.

Though I'm still going to pin my hopes on the bracelet. Does it come in various precious metals? Can I get one blessed by Norman himself? An personalized inscription from Norman would also make it more valuable to me as well as increase its resale value ... I mean, I'd never sell mine but just in case ... on the off chance ...if it did not work .... or something ....

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 11:45
Mike:

<< See, now while that seems obvious in meaning at first blush, when I actually parse it I can't get to the golden nugget within promised by the poetry of its construction without. A problem which keeps me tossing and turning at nights if I read yours or Norman's post too soon before bedtime. >>

In future I shall follow your fine example in your last seven consecutive posts above of how to avoid keeping people awake at night...

... or indeed any other time.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 12:00
Mark,

>>> In future I shall follow your fine example in your last seven consecutive posts above <<<

Seven? Hardly a record for me. But what can you expect when you reduce a nice psychological observation into a biblical platitude ... with Norman lurking in the wings just waiting to pounce? Maybe next we could try a riff on "loaves and fishes"?

>>> of how to avoid keeping people awake at night...

... or indeed any other time. <<<

As always, my life is about nothing if not addressing the problem of rampant insomnia running amok here in this group. Above all, I aim to please.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 12:05
Mike:

<< Would it not make more sense to quote passages from "How to Win Friends and Influence People"? Certainly more relevant in today's world. >>

I think that's a great idea. Let's start with:

"The perfect way to conquer worry: Prayer"

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 12:16
Mike:

<< platitudes designed to teach basic ethics to ancient nomads >>

Nomads?

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 12:21
Mark,

>>> << platitudes designed to teach basic ethics to ancient nomads >>

Nomads? <<<

Well, only sometimes. I guess wandering around in the desert for only 40 years does not fully qualify one's status as a nomad.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 12:24
Mike:

<< But what can you expect when you reduce a nice psychological observation into a biblical platitude >>

I think "reduce" is the right word. Once one has boiled off the excess verbiage, what you are left with is exactly the same as someone said in one short sentence three thousand years ago.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 12:27
Mike:

<< I guess wandering around in the desert for only 40 years does not fully qualify one's status as a nomad. >>

I think you are confusing the story with the audience. The story of the wanderings in the desert doesn't make the original readers (or hearers) of the story into nomads, any more than the story of the Odyssey makes 8th Century land-based Greeks into heroic warriors and wanderers through magic lands.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 12:33
Mark,

>>> << Would it not make more sense to quote passages from "How to Win Friends and Influence People"? Certainly more relevant in today's world. >>

I think that's a great idea. Let's start with:

"The perfect way to conquer worry: Prayer" <<<

No, I was thinking more along the lines of: "If You're Wrong, Admit It"

Or perhaps, in Norman's honor:

"An Easy Way to Become a Good Conversationalist"

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 12:36
Mike:

<< No, I was thinking more along the lines of: "If You're Wrong, Admit It" >>

That might reduce the number of posts in this forum to virtually zero.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 12:37
Mark,

>>> << But what can you expect when you reduce a nice psychological observation into a biblical platitude >>

I think "reduce" is the right word. Once one has boiled off the excess verbiage, what you are left with is exactly the same as someone said in one short sentence three thousand years ago. <<<

But as most good cooks know, if you go to far with the reduction, you end up with a thick brown mess that scarcely resembles the original.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 12:47
Mark,

>>>
<< I guess wandering around in the desert for only 40 years does not fully qualify one's status as a nomad. >>

I think you are confusing the story with the audience. The story of the wanderings in the desert doesn't make the original readers (or hearers) of the story into nomads, any more than the story of the Odyssey makes 8th Century land-based Greeks into heroic warriors and wanderers through magic lands. <<<

Interesting observation. One would have to narrow down the audience by time period, I suppose. Certainly some parts of "The Bible" (and one could certainly pick nits about what that term refers to) were written after the time of some of the audience had passed. Certainly the quotation that spawned this sequence was written later than Moses' time. (Probably around 100-300 AD or so, I guess. But then I've no aspirations as a biblical scholar.) However, taken as a whole, the Bible is a collection of "teaching stories" for that particular culture which was a collection of various tribes (self-described) of nomadic peoples some of whom were more settled fishermen, or farmers or shepherds or whatever else they needed to do to scratch out a living.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 12:47
Mike:

<< But as most good cooks know, if you go to far with the reduction, you end up with a thick brown mess that scarcely resembles the original. >>

Perhaps you'd like to demonstrate to me what additional meaning the "nice psychological observation" has that isn't encompassed in the "biblical platitude".

Just to remind you what it was:

"Life is largely composed of conversations. Conversations are composed of memes. In Level 1 we are unaware of this. In Level 2 we see the world as a solid, understandable body to be interacted with. In Level 3 we see the world as a canvas to be painted, an instrument to be played, or a block of marble to be sculpted by us for our purpose. We choose to do this for good or for evil. If we choose good, good is returned to us in unexpected ways. If we choose evil, evil is returned. Either way, it looks like the way we choose is the way of the world."

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 12:48
Mark,

>>> << No, I was thinking more along the lines of: "If You're Wrong, Admit It" >>

That might reduce the number of posts in this forum to virtually zero. <<<

AH, best forget that one then. ;-)

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 13:03
Mark,

>>> Perhaps you'd like to demonstrate to me what additional meaning the "nice psychological observation" has that isn't encompassed in the "biblical platitude". <<,

Surely ... happy to clarify.

>>> Just to remind you what it was:

"Life is largely composed of conversations. Conversations are composed of memes. In Level 1 we are unaware of this. In Level 2 we see the world as a solid, understandable body to be interacted with. In Level 3 we see the world as a canvas to be painted, an instrument to be played, or a block of marble to be sculpted by us for our purpose. We choose to do this for good or for evil. If we choose good, good is returned to us in unexpected ways. If we choose evil, evil is returned. Either way, it looks like the way we choose is the way of the world." <<<

Thanks. The point I made was that the last sentences contained an observation about the psychology of belief.

"We choose to do this for good or for evil. If we choose good, good is returned to us in unexpected ways. If we choose evil, evil is returned.*** Either way, it looks like the way we choose is the way of the world. *** "

I pointed out that one could more widely see this effect by replacing good/evil with any other pair of beliefs. And the observation was that by holding a belief you get evidence which supports that belief by giving you the appropriate world view.

To the extent that I objected to reducing it to "What you so, you shall reap." it is that the biblical quote is more narrow and refers to the results of action. My point about the original observation is that it has something to say about how one's perception is altered.

It is true, as I previously said, that the original observation was also about actions and results ... but not ONLY about that. Were I to have switched time and culture I might have cited the Buddhist Sutra about the monk carrying the prostitute across the stream. That would have made my argument in a religious context (if there is some virtue to that, and if you call Buddhism a religion).

>>> That is, if it means anything at all. >>>

I guess you get it or you don't. ;-)

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 13:06
Mike:

<< I've no aspirations as a biblical scholar >>

I gathered that.

The quotation in question comes from one of the undisputedly genuine letters of the Apostle Paul to members of the Jewish diaspora in what is now central Anatolia, but was then a predominantly Greek area within the Roman Empire. The date of the letter would have been around A.D. 50.

The people he was addressing would have been predominantly prosperous town dwellers and the main topic of the letter was what to do about non-Jewish (i.e. Greek) converts to the faith.

Nothing in other words could at that time have been further from your picture of various tribes of wandering nomads doing what they could to scratch a living.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 13:13
Mike:

<< The biblical quote is more narrow and refers to the results of action >>

Actually it doesn't. You've mistaken it's meaning because of the erroneous image you have in your mind of wandering nomads doing what they can to scratch a living.

Paul's meaning is precisely about the altering of one's perception, as you will find out if you read the original passage - Galatians 6.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 13:54
Mark,

>>> << I've no aspirations as a biblical scholar >>

I gathered that. <<<

But my advantage is that I don't have to adhere to a particular "truth" about all of this stuff.

>>> The quotation in question comes from one of the undisputedly genuine letters of the Apostle Paul to members of the Jewish diaspora in what is now central Anatolia, but was then a predominantly Greek area within the Roman Empire. The date of the letter would have been around A.D. 50.
I've no particular dog in this fight but I'm doubtful that there is much agreement about most of this. There are a few things that seem to be generally accepted by objective historians

Firstly, the "Bible" is more than what was written about Christ after his death. It is also composed of a mountain of other works written much earlier which took material from even more works from the Jewish heritage. Probably most of that was oral tradition for much of its existence.

Historians date the "New Testament' writings anywhere from" the last half of the First Century" to as long as AD 300 or even later. I suppose it would be a fascinating study if I cared about it even a little. As to the letter you cite ... I dunno. I'm sure it could have been written any time after about AD 30 or so. It wold certainly be the exception, in that case.

>>> The people he was addressing would have been predominantly prosperous town dwellers and the main topic of the letter was what to do about non-Jewish (i.e. Greek) converts to the faith.

Nothing in other words could at that time have been further from your picture of various tribes of wandering nomads doing what they could to scratch a living. <<<

Which might be relevant to what I said if I thought that the "Bible" was a single quote from a single letter written by a single person to a single group of people living in a single town. The "Bible" as I and most others, I believe, understand it is a comprehensive part of the Judeo-Christian cannon which did indeed serve as a ethical teaching tool to a wide audience, some of whom were nomadic and most of whom were fairly uneducated and illiterate who lived over many centuries. Obviously some were merchant-traders. Others had substantial education ... but they were not the primary audience. They were the "establishment" and so "above" the whole debate ... as is so often the case.

I seriously doubt that the Jewish people object to being characterized as "nomadic tribes" as that is the way the Bible describes them at various points ... and they WROTE the damn thing! Certainly they retained editorial rights! LOL ;-)

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 14:08
Mike:

I have absolutely no idea what relevance all this is supposed to have to the question of the meaning and context of the particular quotation I used.

By your own admission you know absolutely nothing about the subject. So you're about in the same position as I would be if I tried to win an argument about American Football with the coach of the Boston Red Stockings.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 14:10
Mark,

>>> << The biblical quote is more narrow and refers to the results of action >>

Actually it doesn't. You've mistaken it's meaning because of the erroneous image you have in your mind of wandering nomads doing what they can to scratch a living. <<<

My conclusion derives from the words, not the audience, in fact.

>>> Paul's meaning is precisely about the altering of one's perception, as you will find out if you read the original passage - Galatians 6. <<<

That is the whole problem with this "interpertation" stuff. If you read the quote in context (which I did just to play along this morning) it is about circumcision and doing good deeds and not posing for others and a last self-serving bit about not causing him trouble because he knew Jesus. For pity's sake! You can interpret that thing anyway you like. Ancient day "spin control". ROTF ;)

Actually, the quote is what the quote is. I don't think I've mistaken its meaning because it is a rather simple metaphor which does not require someone to interpret it. That wold defeat the whole purpose of using a simple metaphor.

"As you sow ..." An Action
".. so you will reap." a second action with a result from the first action.

That is pretty dead bang obvious to me! Yes, it could have been a diatribe on recruiting techniques for Greeks, who knows how it was delivered. But it is STILL about action and result. It is still NOT about the psychological mechanism of belief. It is about doing "good" or you will not GET "good". It is not at all about: if you do good you will believe the world is a good place.

Reply by Jacqueline

2010-04-27 14:12
FWIW before anyone gets too excited about the WWND bracelets - I was using the bracelet as an anti-Oracle - sort of a "WWND"? and then just do the opposite. I've thrown it out anyway and switched over to my "WWSD" bracelet (Sparky being my golden retriever).

Although I do seem to be chasing after balls a bit too much lately and have a strong desire to stop in the vicinity of trees, it's been pretty useful as he just works hard, plays hard, sleeps a lot, doesn't waste any time on other members of the species who aren't worth his time, and is just basically happy and friendly for no apparent reason.

This excerpt from one of Brodie's articles seems kinda relevant here too:

"Sometimes I do want advice. I only take advice from people with lives I like. Most people, if they take advice, take it from people they like or people like them. I take the position that taking advice will make my life more like the life of the advice-giver. So I take financial advice from people who are richer than me (not some self-appointed “financial advisor”), relationship advice from men who are happy and fulfilled in their relationships (not Dr. Laura), advice on public speaking from successful public speakers (not self-appointed “speaking coaches”), and so on.

Finally, when giving feedback, it’s great to use the Communication Model. That separates out raw perceptions, interpretations, and feelings, making the feedback more accurate and easier to receive. Always use “I” and talk about yourself. Don’t attempt to philosophize and generalize that all human beings are the way you are. They aren’t. Thank God."

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 14:22
Hey Mark,

>>> I have absolutely no idea what relevance all this is supposed to have to the question of the meaning and context of the particular quotation I used. <<<

Not my fault. For some reason you wanted to pursue me to the ends of the earth because of a tangential comment about the audience for the Bible being nomadic ... so here we are ... way out in the field smelling the wild flowers. I think you pretty much took us here with when Paul wrote his letter and who he wrote it to and why he felt the need to write the letter in the first place.

I'm still back with the actual words and the contained metaphor -- which I'm STILL saying is not a bit like the idea that one's world view is influenced by one's belief in how one should live in the world.

But I have to say, the trip was nice and the wild flowers out here smell wonderful. ;-)

Reply by learning as I go

2010-04-27 14:24
Amen to that, Jacq!
learning as I go

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 14:28
Mike:

I pursued you to the end of the world?

I suggest you count the number of words we each used. All I've said is that the quote was not directed at a nomadic audience, and is not just related to action but to the way we see the world. All the other stuff has come from you.

"We choose to do this for good or for evil. If we choose good, good is returned to us in unexpected ways. If we choose evil, evil is returned"

"As you sow, so shall you reap".

I still haven't got the faintest idea why you think the first quote isn't just a more long-winded way of saying what the second quote says. Where do you get all the stuff about "the idea that one's world view is influenced by one's belief in how one should live in the world".

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 14:38
Mark,

>>> By your own admission you know absolutely nothing about the subject. So you're about in the same position as I would be if I tried to win an argument about American Football with the coach of the Boston Red Socks. <<<

O.K. Flag on the play. Firstly, I did not "admit" anything ... what I said was that I have no aspirations to be a biblical scholar. So let's just clarify that point.

Next, I'm not trying to win an argument about New Testament Facts (for $400, please Alex). I think it pays to keep in mind where this started. I illustrated something with a quotation by Richard Brodie and you "simplified" it to a New Testament quote. I then both an on point observation that the New Testament quote had a different point entirely and that in general, the purpose for the bible was to condense ethical teachings to simple platitudes that would be easily assimilated by the ignorant illiterate nomadic peoples who were it's main audience.

Following that it somehow took a hard left turn into angels dancing on the points of pins and such .. none of which things, no matter what the outcome of the discussion, would have the slightest bearing on my original comment about the meaning of the metaphor vs. the meaning of the Brodie quote.

I'm not sure why you think that I care who wrote which letter to whom and when and for what reason. That seems to be far more interesting to you than me and if Paul wrote the letter to the Chinese in 1996 I not care a bit ... I'd be a bit astonished, but I'd not care or see its relevance to my point.

But to pick up on your baseball example ... this feels like Dejavu all over again.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 14:50
Mike:

I've no idea about what all this blather has to do with what I've been saying. You seem to work on the principle that the more words you produce the more you think you've won the argument.

The only point I was trying to make was that the quotation was not directed at a nomadic audience and was not intended to be taken purely literally. That in fact it means, considerably more succinctly, what Broggle said.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 14:51
>>> I pursued you to the end of the world?

I suggest you count the number of words we each used. <<<


But that is your style, Mark. You use few words, leaving much to interpertation, then use all of that wiggle room to pick a direction ... then off you go. I use as many words as I can possibly fit in to make sure that I won't be misinterpreted .. but alas. ....

>>> All I've said is that the quote was not directed at a nomadic audience, <<<

Yeah, but that is all you talking to yourself ... it has little to do with my first point. If I'd have said that the "Bivle" does not say ... Then the argument would have been all about how "Bible" is not spelled with a "V".

Start with Brodie and end with Galcians 6 and how to interpret it in Roman Catholic Cannon and you wonder why we are off in the weeds?

>>> and is not just related to action but to the way we see the world. All the other stuff has come from you. >>>

You really see it that way?

>>> << We choose to do this for good or for evil. If we choose good, good is returned to us in unexpected ways. If we choose evil, evil is returned. >>

In what way is this not about action? <<<

Arrrrrrrrrg, go back to the beginning where I said: "Especially the last couple of sentences.: ("Either way, it looks like the way we choose is the way of the world", etc.)

How is it possible that you think that my point has been about actions and not beliefs and world view when I said exactly what I meant with, as Norm would say -- lotsa words?

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 14:56
Mike:

<< How is it possible that you think that my point has been about actions and not beliefs and world view >>

That's the trouble, Mike. I don't think that, have never said that I did, and several times have said exactly the opposite. So arguing with you is a highly frustrating process.

And now, to everyone's great relief, I'm going to stop. You can have the last word - or words.

Reply by Jacqueline

2010-04-27 15:04
Er - given that I see that Broggle / Brodie has taken a similar path to myself (same seminars, read the same books) - I would say that Mike's interpretation of his words was correct.

Not that the biblical stuff isn't true too, but it's just not what he was saying.

Wow, interpretations are so much about the individual's context, it's downright freaky.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 15:07
Mark,

>>> I've no idea about what all this blather has to do with what I've been saying. <<<

I think the point is that what you've been saying has nothing to do with I originally said.

>>> You seem to work on the principle that the more words you produce the more you think you've won the argument. <<<

I was not under the impression that there was an argument. I thought you had just missed the point I made. However, when I got Galatians 6 I should have gotten the message that I was being taken for a ride.

>>> The only point I was trying to make was that the quotation was not directed at a nomadic audience and was not intended to be taken purely literally. That in fact it means, considerably more succinctly, what Brogle said. <<<

Yeah, I got that you were saying that. The fact that it had not the slightest relation to the point I made seems obviously not that important to you. I could be wrong, but "blather" kind of gives it away, yeah?

At this point shall we simply agree that I'm a conceptual dunce and you are an astute student of New Testament history? I think that might be best to keep the peace.

I'm going to take a short break to do something that won't be found in Galatians 6.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 15:28
Jacqueline:

<< Er - given that I see that Broggle / Brodie has taken a similar path to myself (same seminars, read the same books) - I would say that Mike's interpretation of his words was correct. >>

I never had any problem with Mike's interpretation of Blogle's words, though for some reason he seems to think I did. I would say his interpretation was correct too.

My problem was with his rather contemptuous dismissal of the NT quote as a moral platitude for nomads. Which was both a facile argument and factually incorrect. That's all.

Reply by Will

2010-04-27 15:35
"<< No, I was thinking more along the lines of: "If You're Wrong, Admit It" >>

That might reduce the number of posts in this forum to virtually zero."

Surely it would simply add half a dozen comments to each post?

I love these hypotheticals!

Reply by Jacqueline

2010-04-27 15:46
Well, that's good that everyone's right and all is well with the world.

Only bad thing about the tangents is that there can be some good stuff above that never gets revisited. Then the thread gets locked on the 100th Monkey, which is usually Norman out of sheer verbosity. Just not fair. :-)

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 16:39
Mark,

While respecting your desire to end it "back there" ...

>>> I never had any problem with Mike's interpretation of Blogle's words, though for some reason he seems to think I did. I would say his interpretation was correct too. <<<



>>> My problem was with his rather contemptuous dismissal of the NT quote as a moral platitude for nomads. Which was both a facile argument and factually incorrect. That's all. <<<

Just to clarify, if that is even remotely possible: My comment about nomads was not made with contempt. The bible is much like Aesop's Fables. It serves the same function. Reading and writing were not that common before last week or so and therefore the necessary function of educating the populace about what is ethically required of them came down to stories and songs and jingles and such. The majority of the Jewish people (and most people, I guess) were lower class and therefore that was how they got their ethical education. I don't consider that to be a contemptuous statement either ... it is just the way it was.

Reply by learning as I go

2010-04-27 17:07
Hi Mike
and you stated:
it is just the way it was.
ROTFL!.....and it still is in my world. I live in a brain of metaphorical references! *blush*

Jacq:
Simply stated: You're wonderful!
learning as I go

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 17:17
Mike:

f<< Reading and writing were not that common before last week or so and therefore the necessary function of educating the populace about what is ethically required of them came down to stories and songs and jingles and such. >>

There I'd definitely have to disagree with you. Literacy has always been highly prized among the Jews, and every Jewish boy was and is expected to be able to read from the Torah and expound it. The first time he does it with the congregation is a great occasion called the Bar Mitzvah.

Jesus, as an adult male Jew, was invited to read from the scriptures in the synogogue at Nazareth - which was quite normal practice. His expounding of the prophet Isaiah didn't go down too well though!

Reply by learning as I go

2010-04-27 17:46
I give up... What what meant by arguing football with a baseball coach? You guys are flying over my head! *blush*
learning as I go

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 17:53
>>> There I'd definitely have to disagree with you. Literacy has always been highly prized among the Jews, and every Jewish boy was and is expected to be able to read from the Torah and expound it. <<<

Guys,

I'm opting out of what has become religious debate. I simply won't be drawn in further. Sorry, who knew a simple observation about a comment about belief would lead where it has. I guess when religion plays a role, simple reason and exchange of ideas suffers.

Reply by Mike

2010-04-27 17:57
Hey Learning,

>>> I give up... What what meant by arguing football with a baseball coach? You guys are flying over my head! *blush* <<<

Over my head as well. But it did give me an opening for my Dejavu reference ;-)

Metaphors, memes and Jesus, what more can a body want on a nice Tuesday ;-)

Reply by learning as I go

2010-04-27 18:21
Hi Mike
Maybe it means that a baseball coach is so focused on his sport that he isn't expected to know any more about an entirely different sport than one who doesn't follow it at all.
But the both of you lost me way back so I wouldn't know how that would fit in even if I did guess the reference correctly! The combination of lack of knowledge PLUS a lousy short term memory really leaves me in the dust.....or ancient desert sands!
vickie

Reply by Alan Baljeu

2010-04-27 18:43
Marks point (if it even matters anymore) was that Mark being ignorant of American sports means he shouldn't debate you on the subject. Just as Mike's obvious ignorance of the cultural background of biblical writings also doesn't merit debate.

Reply by learning as I go

2010-04-27 18:49
Hi Alan B.
aaaahhh...thank you! That makes sense!
vickie

Reply by learning as I go

2010-04-27 18:53
Hi Allan B.
I'm in the rare position of being so ahead on my important work that I decided to hop through the rabbit tail that Mark and Mike provided....but, alas, I wasn't up to the task at all! blush
vickie

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-27 19:27
There is nothing I like more than to pull someone's strings and watch a thread go boom. Hello Mike.

To go through and correct everything mentioned here would take forever. Mark being slightly smarter than me has already done a good job.

(BTW, that is the intelligence scale here, I have already said Mark > Me > Mel.)

A couple points that have to be made:

Mike all those "different" "systems of thought" I listed are on a steady genealogy. One beget the next with a greater degree of nonsense. Research your history of Transcendentalism and where it intersects with New Thought and you will clearly see the development and emphasis of utter craziness along the way. Start with Transcendentalism in wikipedia and just click a bunch of links.

The scandal in American thought is that this thread and possibility of home grown thought derailed the more interesting and promising pragmatism. Oddly, in engagement with Continental thought, pragmatism is gaining favor once again. Even that old Kraut Nietzsche saw this when he said something to the effect: "In Emerson we lost a great Philosopher."

THOUGHTS INFLUENCING CANCER: This must be said loudly: BS. Never been demonstrated in any significant study. It is *utter* BS. In fact, I defy you to develop a method to test this. Whoever said this needs study double-blind, placebo methodology more and pick up a statistics text and look at the laughable "studies" which showed a CORRELATION between ATTITUDE and possible higher rates of survival from cancer.

Nothing like telling a family member of someone who died of cancer that their loved one just didn't think properly.

The American infatuation with the "law of attraction" is a cultural embarrassment. And yes it is a thoroughly American obsession, even if it is spreading throughout the rest of the Western world.

And I don't want to hear about "Eastern" "philosophy" having similar elements. That is a long and difficult argument involving translations of enormous and difficult texts written in languages which make Greek philology look like a snap, gulfs in history, and culture.

To be sure, what generally passes for "Eastern Philosophy" (as if something could exist) is throughly thought through and understood via Western metaphysics, especially the dominant variety as understood and practiced in America. No matter what gurus to Hollywood celebrities like the Dalai Lama would say.

We are still pondering the beginnings of our own tradition, to think we could have an inkling of another without first throughly understanding our own is hubris.

There. That should be good for another 60 posts.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 19:31
Mike:

>>> I give up... What what meant by arguing football with a baseball coach? You guys are flying over my head! *blush* <<<

<< Over my head as well. But it did give me an opening for my Dejavu reference ;-) >>

I'm glad Alan at least understood what I was talking about. For the rest of you I will spell it out. I was attempting to demonstrate my complete ignorance of American Football by mentioning an AF team, but failing to realise that it was actually a baseball team and even then I got the team name wrong - did you notice that? - just how blatantly obvious do I have to be?

Your deja vu reference was presumably to my pointing out that your knowledge of Marxism was about the same as your knowledge of the cultural background of Biblical references. But that was in another Forum - they do things differently there.

Reply by Jacqueline

2010-04-27 19:34
Hey Vickie,

I think (my interpretation of course) that the real "message" - and the beautiful irony - of the whole conversation is that the conversation itself was actually an ideal example of how an individual's context and way of *being* in the world will influence how they approach things and what they even SEE to approach. It's all that filter and methods of action bias stuff, which is kind of fascinating to watch in other people. I just wish it was as easy to do with ourselves.

It's not impossible though, I used to be like a dog with a bone in arguing my point, very dogmatic, always had to be right, etc. I still feel it come up sometimes, but I've told the internal dog to shut up and tried to spend more time listening to others (and for understanding - so more than what they say but the context and meaning) than talking for so many years that it works most of the time. Probably still do it without meaning to even though I hate it when others do it to me. So clearly I'm not sowing enough compassion and understanding to be able to reap the results I want. :-)

Sigh.. lunch is over.. no time to read any more brilliant manifestos.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 19:41
Jacqueline:

<< the conversation itself was actually an ideal example of how an individual's context and way of *being* in the world will influence how they approach things and what they even SEE to approach. >>

Absolutely right. You and Mike were both unable to see that I actually understood Mike's interpretation of Brodie perfectly well, because you both presumably thought that I was trying to defend or introduce a Christian point of view. But if you look at what I actually wrote, it could just as easily have been said by an atheist or an agnostic.

Reply by Seraphim

2010-04-27 20:20
This thread has got me really intrigued about Mark's new TM system! I haven't seen him so actively posting in months! Presumably he is making progress on his larger goals, while also being able to spend more time in these discussions.

So Mark - when's the system coming?? :-)

Reply by Mel

2010-04-27 21:08
Mike: For some reason, I recalled you balking at the term world view in the past. What I did find was you stating that we had a similar one. Maybe I'm remembering something from your Yahoo group? Or maybe you never had a problem with it.

Mark: For the record, I am in full agreement with your statements about the Bible. I've had similar disagreements with Mike. One thing you have to give Mike credit for is that he is so confident in his views (however erroneous) that you find yourself wondering if you've lost your mind. LOL

Norman: I hate to drop in my intelligence rankings, but I am not in agreement about our state of mind and cancer. Ultimately I believe God is in control and it's silly and even immoral to blame someone for dying of cancer. Yet I do know that our bodies tend to obey our minds. Note that I said "tend to." This is not a certain relationship. I would have a hard time willing my body to grow a third arm. But I might have very little trouble willing myself into some kind of sickness either because I am depressed or have been told by a physician that I won't live. I'm not as skeptical of the research on beliefs and health as you are. We just have to be careful not to exclude biology (or in a Christian's case, the will of God). But is there a relationship? Absolutely. Even if simply a relationship between long-term fear and immune system suppression. If you're going to move someone up to my place in the intelligence hierarchy, my vote is for Seraphim as he knew enough not to jump into this debate. lol

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 21:09
Seraphim:

Good question! It got a bit stuck at one stage, but I'm now back on the development.

My largest goal at the moment is that I've just been put in charge of the fund raising for a £500,000 church re-ordering appeal.

Somehow I never seem to be able to get away from my past!

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 21:12
Mel:

<< But I might have very little trouble willing myself into some kind of sickness either because I am depressed or have been told by a physician that I won't live. >>

This evening I really didn't feel like going to a meeting, but was prevented from going because I started to develop some early symptoms of flu - which miraculously dispersed after I had settled down with my wife to watch the latest episode of NCIS.

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-27 21:28
I am tired of OT run away threads. What happened to the post count limit.

Reply by Norman U.

2010-04-27 21:45
What one believes and what is true are rarely the same.

Believe all you want that "positive thoughts" (whatever that is) cure cancer. Just show me the peer-reviewed study which has been reproduced more than a couple dozen times.

Just because a "thought" can seemingly trivially affect a physiological response hardly means it can significantly impact the complexity what happens during cancer.

Even if a tight correlation were discovered, which it never has been, not even a statistically significant one, then the question becomes one of the nature of correlation. More than likely a result of a shared causation or tightly correlation with the causation.

The most surprising study in field of the affect of the "mind" on health is the recent study about the increasing power of the placebo and nocebo effects in the Western world.

The problem with the study is not so much its reliability but its conclusion that things like the placebo or nocebo effect having anything to do with something like a "mind" and the "mind" has something to do with a brain.

What role something like a "mind" might have to do with *anything* has almost nothing to do with science and everything to do with philosophy or more likely thinking. But that is antiquated nowadays. We have decided to let the cognitive scientists (computer programmers) become the high priests of the care of mind, body, and soul. Er I mean algorithms, hardware, and the possible sufficiently complex calculus capable of skirting by Goedel's incompleteness theorems.

Time to go think my dishes clean. If it can sure cancer certainly it can do that.

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 21:54
Norman:

<< What happened to the post count limit? >>

It only applies to other people.

But, seriously, you are right. Time to close this one down. One more post though...

Reply by Mark Forster

2010-04-27 22:35
Mike:

<< I'm opting out of what has become religious debate. I simply won't be drawn in further. Sorry, who knew a simple observation about a comment about belief would lead where it has. I guess when religion plays a role, simple reason and exchange of ideas suffers. >>

I don't know why you consider that giving correct historical information about the literacy of the Jews makes it into a religious debate. As I said before, I've said nothing in this exchange with you which couldn't have been said by an atheist or an agnostic.